‘It’s almost a no-win role’:Why you won’t see an Australian as India’s $2 million coach

Ricky Ponting created headlines this week by relaying his son Fletcher’s enthusiasm for the idea of Dad accepting the BCCI’s entreaties to become head coach of India.

“He said,‘Just take it Dad,we would love to move over there for the next couple of years’,”Ponting told the ICC website. “That’s how much they love being over there and the culture of cricket in India,but,right now,it probably doesn’t exactly fit into my lifestyle.”

Ricky Ponting in discussion with Shikhar Dhawan during his role as Delhi Capitals coach in the IPL.

Ricky Ponting in discussion with Shikhar Dhawan during his role as Delhi Capitals coach in the IPL.Getty

As well as a nice insight into father and son,the anecdote also conveyed what the Indian Premier League has done for Australian suitors to the job of coaching India in all formats – with a price tag of between $1 and $2 million,easily the highest paid such position in the game.

Even for that money,Ponting and company can afford to be ambivalent,because of the balance of income and lifestyle that IPL gigs offer them.

In Lucknow,where Justin Langer had coached in the IPL for the first time this year,he took a similar view of the dimensions of the challenge and the work he was already doing.

Langer,Ponting,and Trevor Bayliss are the three Australian head coaches – Kiwi and Australian assistant coach Dan Vettori is also a head coach. Mike Hussey,Brad Haddin,Simon Helmot,Adam Griffith and James Hopes are among those with assistant roles.

Ravi Shastri (right) was a successful mentor on two tours of Australia.

Ravi Shastri (right) was a successful mentor on two tours of Australia.AP

“It would almost be the biggest job in cricket being the head coach of the Indian cricket team because of the huge volume of cricket,the huge expectation,” Langer said. “It would be a great challenge,it would be great fun. It would be a wonderful opportunity to win ICC titles,but with all these things,the timing has got to be right.

“I did four or so years with the Australian cricket team. It’s all-encompassing. It is exhausting and I think someone else like Rahul Dravid will probably tell you the same thing,Ravi Shastri will tell you the same thing. The pressure on winning for the Indian team is massive.”

That pressure was certainly felt by Greg Chappell when in 2005 he became the first Australian to take the job. His tenure was marked by plenty of internal conflict,especially with the sometime captain,Sourav Ganguly. But it also ended in 2007,right on the cusp of the IPL and the offer of T20 coaching jobs that were not quite so demanding.

In the here and now,Chappell doubts that the BCCI (the Indian cricket board) would pick an Australian coach. Nor does he think those in the mix would want to accept its demanding terms. “I’m not sure many want to do 10 months on the road,especially if they can do media work,” he said. “It’s almost a no-win role.”

India’s current coach,Rahul Dravid,has done the job for three years and will finish after the T20 World Cup. His predecessor,Ravi Shastri,managed to hang onto the role for five,including successive winning Test tours of Australia.

There is a growing view that,as the BCCI lurches closer into a tight relationship with the nationalist government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi,it is less likely that an overseas coach will be called upon to mentor India’s top players.

But at the same time,the bevy of high-paying IPL jobs available make it necessary for any candidate to weigh up income,time at home and the relative stress levels of the job. For most,the calculation invariably results in a polite reluctance to go into full-time international coaching.

Hussey,an assistant coach with the Chennai Super Kings in the IPL and also the head coach of Welsh Fire in the Hundred,arrived home from India this week and is looking forward to a couple of months of home comforts before flying to England. He will then get another break of similar length before he commentates at home for Fox Cricket.

“They play more cricket than probably anyone in the world really,they’re literally going from tour to tour to tour,” Hussey said of India’s national side. “So that would be a pretty challenging sort of role where you’d have to be there,boots on the ground. You’re probably only getting the IPL off,which is eight to 10 weeks,but then the rest of the year you’re going to be pretty much on the go.

“Certainly as a full-time international coach,it’s not something at this stage of my life that I’m that keen on. Out of playing and even now,it’s not really on my radar,and I’m enjoying the balance of being able to coach as an assistant or head coach,then doing a bit of media as well.

“I love that balance and still spending some time at home. You’d always like more time at home,but the bucket is pretty full at the moment.”

Alongside Hussey on the CSK coaching staff is Stephen Fleming,the erudite former New Zealand captain,who has been raised as a possible India coach more times than almost any other candidate. The likes of John Wright (New Zealand),Gary Kirsten (South Africa) and Duncan Fletcher (Zimbabwe) have been successful India coaches by offering a quiet,phlegmatic guiding hand of the kind Fleming has mastered at CSK.

Gautam Gambhir with Virender Sehwag.

Gautam Gambhir with Virender Sehwag.AFP

“It just goes to show how highly regarded he is on the world stage but particularly in India,” Hussey said. “But I don’t think he’d entertain the idea,he loves the balance as well. He probably finds it a little bit amusing that his name keeps coming up,but pretty honoured that he’s in the mix.”

The candidate most likely,it seems,to succeed Dravid may now be the feisty Gautam Gambhir,who has lately served as a mentor for Kolkata Knight Riders.

Extremely combative as a player – he was once suspended for a Test for elbowing Shane Watson,and had more than one on-field confrontation with Virat Kohli in the IPL – Gambhir has also been an outspoken advocate for change in the Indian coaching system,especially the handling of younger players.

Gambhir has,too,worn the Indian flag very much on his sleeve,while also professing admiration for the team-oriented nature of Australian cricket. Towards the back end of his Test career,he once travelled to Australia to work one-on-one with Langer.

“There has been a culture in Delhi cricket about making players insecure,” Gambhir said in 2017. “I have myself faced that when I was a youngster. When I got into the Ranji Trophy team,I was made to feel insecure. Then only I had decided,if I ever take charge I will never make young boys feel insecure.”

Shastri succeeded as both a public advocate for team India but also as the cultivator of a secure dressing room,notably inthe COVID-affected 2020-21 series win Down Under. Whoever ends up coach of India,that is the kind of balance their players will dearly hope for in Australia this summer.

News,results and expert analysis from the weekend of sport sent every Monday.Sign up for our Sport newsletter.

Daniel Brettig is The Age's chief cricket writer and the author of several books on cricket.

Most Viewed in Sport