But this is Gillian Anderson and Rufus Sewell inScoop,a Netflix film that recreates the 2019 encounter in meticulous detail.
Gillian Anderson and Rufus Sewell star as Emily Maitlis and the Duke of York in Scoop.Netflix
Sewell spent three hours a day in the make-up chair to resemble Prince Andrew,while Anderson studied the interview and watched episodes ofNewsnight to capture Maitlis’ mannerisms.
The film,due for release in the northern hemisphere spring,is a behind-the-scenes look at how the interview was secured and the way it unfolded,framed as a tribute to the work of the four women responsible.
It is based onScoops by Sam McAlister,the “booker extraordinaire” onNewsnight who negotiated the interview in which the duke was questioned about his friendship with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
McAlister is played on screen by Billie Piper. In addition to Anderson as Maitlis,the film features Keeley Hawes as Amanda Thirsk,the duke’s right-hand woman. Romola Garai plays Esme Wren,theNewsnight editor.
The room at Buckingham Palace in which the interview took place is also recreated in minute detail.Netflix
“It’s rare that you see a representation of women,all in their 40s and 50s. This is an opportunity to see hard-working women behind the scenes at every stage,” McAlister said.
She was on set during filming and said Anderson’s likeness to Maitlis is “astonishing”.
“It felt like being there with Emily,” McAlister said. “Everything about her physicality and her performance is on the money. They have a similar intellect as well. Emily is very methodical. She worked very hard on every interview;she trains,she studies. And my impression of Gillian was exactly the same. She was studying the material,she was studying Emily,and she was working on that project in an intellectual way as well as a dramatic way.”
Philip Martin,Scoop’s director,said of Sewell:“Rufus spent about three hours in the make-up chair. He started really early in the morning and had to go through this strange process of putting a bald wig on before the other stuff went on. We worked very hard to make all of the prosthetics flexible and light enough so that he could act through it all.”
To look like the Duke of York,Rufus Sewell had to spend three hours a day in the make-up chair.Getty
“With Gillian,there are no prosthetics – it’s make-up and a wig and mannerisms,” said Martin
Both actors spent hours watching the interview as part of their preparation,and Anderson also studied Maitlis’ presenting style onNewsnight.
“Sometimes people can do a really brilliant impersonation but not capture something about the person. What Gillian and Rufus have done so brilliantly is get the spirit of the people that they’re playing,so that it feels real,” said Martin.
The room at Buckingham Palace in which the interview took place is also recreated in minute detail,and the camera angles from the original BBC interview are matched exactly.
Gillian Anderson stars as Emily Maitlis (left).Getty
The film,with a script by Peter Moffat,will not be a hatchet job on the duke. “We don’t take a side – we’re not saying,‘Oh,isn’t he great,’ or,‘Oh,isn’t he evil’. It’s for the viewer to draw their own inferences,” said McAlister.
Martin,who also directed the first two series ofThe Crown,said:“I think lots of people would tie themselves up in knots because they didn’t want to appear to approve of Andrew,or to disapprove of him. Rufus wasn’t afraid of that.
“Andrew was slightly the Harry of his era. He was seen as a great communicator with great people skills in his 20s and 30s,a person who could get things done. I think Rufus really understood that side of things,and the sense that Andrew is older now but has a sparkle and a kind of charisma to him.
Prince Andrew answered questions regarding his association with Jeffery Epstein during the BBC interview.BBC
“It doesn’t feel like we’re pointing an arrow at him and saying,‘This is a bad guy’. You’re seeing a person,and that’s a real tribute to Rufus’ take on it.”
The duke was pilloried for his answers to Maitlis,which included a claim that he was physically unable to sweat and an alibi placing him in the Woking branch of Pizza Express.
Martin said the tone of the film would reflect the absurd elements of the interview as well as the serious issues at hand.
“There was something slightly surreal about the whole process. So we’ve tried to make it have a bounce and a bite to it. It moves fast and it’s absorbing to watch.”
McAlister,a criminal barrister before joining theNewsnight team,left the BBC to write her book and said it felt “bonkers” for her behind-the-scenes producer role to be the subject of a Netflix film.
Scoop is one of two dramatisations in the works.
Maitlis is making her own three-part drama covering her career and culminating in theNewsnight interview.
“It’s nice that there’s so much interest in the story and I’m really looking forward to watching Emily’s,” McAlister said.
She lamented the cuts toNewsnight,which will see the BBC Two show curtailed to a half-hour slot with fewer staff.
“It’s a real shame. This story changed the course of journalistic history. It was a huge thing,and where do you get that kind of journalism? The places that you get it now are diminishing by the second,so to seeNewsnight culled is painful because the powerful will sleep more comfortably in their beds at night.
“It’s a very important type of journalism and it’s disappearing before our eyes,” McAlister said.
However,she acknowledged thatNewsnight’s viewing figures are falling. “It’s what I call ‘the beautiful hypocrisy’,” she said.
“I often do events where people say,‘Newsnight’s amazing,I can’t believe it’s being culled’. And then I’ll politely inquire when they last watched it,and 90 per cent of the time they haven’t watched it for two or three years. The space between what people value in theory and what they actually consume is quite vast.”
The London Telegraph
Find out the next TV,streaming series and movies to add to your must-sees. delivered every Thursday.