TikTok lags on extremism as MPs call out graphic content on platform

TikTok is the only social media giant not signed up to a global anti-extremism pact,Australia’s top internet regulator says,as MPs call out the Chinese-owned company for the proliferation of graphic content stemming from the Hamas-Israel war on its platform.

As theUS government threatens to ban the app to force it out of Chinese hands,Australia’s eSafety commissioner,Julie Inman Grant,announced she had issued legal notices to Google (YouTube),Meta (Facebook and Instagram),Twitter/X,WhatsApp,Telegram and Reddit forcing them to explain steps they had taken to remove terrorist and violent extremist material.

Australian eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant has issued legal notices to multiple tech giants.

Australian eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant has issued legal notices to multiple tech giants.Martin Ollman

TikTok was not among the groups targeted in Inman Grant’s social media enforcement,but Inman Grant said it was newer and regulators had insufficient tools to track its behaviour,flagging a focus on TikTok in her next round of legal notices.

Emphasising TikTok’s harmful algorithm,Inman Grant said in an interview on Monday she had given a presentation on social media to an attorney-general advisory board whose members were “gobsmacked” that big tech was not doing the basics on monitoring content and were “going backwards” from previous standards.

“Any form of terrorist and violent extremist material is either designed to divide and cause fear or spread propaganda,” she said.

“It comes from ideologues from a range of different stripes. It’s meant to have a corrosive impact on people and therefore social cohesion and even democracy.”

The US House of Representatives has passed a bill that could lead to a nationwide TikTok ban.

TikTok,which has 8.5 million users in Australia and more than a billion globally,has become the subject of heated political debate due to a US push for its Chinese owner,ByteDance,to divest the company to reduce national security risks as companies in China are obliged to co-operate with the Chinese Communist Party.

Opposition home affairs spokesman James Paterson,a frequent TikTok critic,and Labor MP Josh Burns said tech companies must help maintain social cohesion by clamping down on violent depictions of events such as the Israel-Hamas war,which Paterson said was all over the popular video-sharing app.

Paterson has labelled TikTok a “bad-faith actor” and urged the Albanese government to join other countries in curbing Chinese influence on TikTok’s operations.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said on Saturday that Labor had no plans to move beyond existing rules stopping government officials from using TikTok on phones with sensitive information.

On Monday,senior minister Tanya Plibersek said:“We’ll take the advice of our security and intelligence agencies on anything we need to do around TikTok. I think people should be careful of the data that they put online in general. Like I say,if the security and intelligence agencies give us advice on TikTok,we’ll take it.”

The Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism,established in 2017 and designed to share information to clamp down on violent content,includes all major social media platforms except for TikTok.

“[TikTok] is sort of behind the rest of the companies,” Inman Grant said,noting that other members of the group may be uncomfortable co-operating with a Chinese-owned firm. “But they are in a class of themselves because they’re not part of these broader groups.”

A TikTok spokeswoman was unable to comment on the platform’s non-involvement in the global forum. TikTok,however,is a member of the United Nations-backed group Tech Against Terrorism.

Paterson,who has consistently backed Israel in its war in Gaza,said some of the most graphic content online from the war existed on TikTok.

Burns,a Jewish MP,said the eSafety commissioner’s warnings were important,adding that platforms such as TikTok had “a responsibility to ensure they are not exacerbating tensions within society,or radicalising people”.

Greens leader Adam Bandt said:“The growing alarm about the slaughter of civilians is not the result of an algorithm,but the brutal reality of the invasion of Gaza that Labor continues to support.”

The EU warned TikTok in October about “disinformation” spreading on the platform after Hamas’ terrorist attack on Israel,which killed about 1200 Israelis. More than 31,000 Palestinians have been killed since the war began,according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry.

In November,TikTok said it was countering antisemitism and had removed millions of videos related to hate speech,hateful behaviour,harassment and bullying.

Cut through the noise of federal politics with news,views and expert analysis.Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.

Paul Sakkal is federal political correspondent for The Age and Sydney Morning Herald who previously covered Victorian politics and has won two Walkley awards.

Most Viewed in Politics