Young college graduates,even those with degrees from the United States,face limited white-collar job prospects and low wages. Housing in the best cities has become too expensive for first-time buyers. Young people who have borrowed from a new generation of online lenders,like Ma's Ant Group,have debts they increasingly resent.
For all of China's economic success,a long-running resentment of the rich,sometimes called the wealthy-hating complex,has long bubbled below the surface. With Ma,it has emerged with a vengeance.
"An outstanding people's billionaire like Jack Ma will definitely be hanged on top of the lamppost,"an online commentator wrote in a widely circulated social media post,referring to the famous lynching slogan in the French Revolution,"À la lanterne!"The article was liked 122,000 times on the Twitter-like Weibo platform and read more than 100,000 times on the messaging and social media app WeChat.
The Communist Party seems more than willing to tap into that resentment. This could mean trouble ahead for entrepreneurs and private businesses under Xi Jinping,China's top leader,who values servility and loyalty above everything else.
You can either have absolute control,or you can have a dynamic,innovative economy. But it's doubtful you can have both.
Fred Hu,founder of Primavera Capital Group
In an annual leadership meeting last week that set the tone for the country's economic policies for the coming year,the party vowed to strengthen antitrust measures and prevent"the disorderly expansion of capital."
Some businesspeople say that the hostility toward Ant and Ma makes them wonder about the fundamental direction of the country.
"You can either have absolute control,or you can have a dynamic,innovative economy,"said Fred Hu,founder of the investment firm Primavera Capital Group in Hong Kong."But it's doubtful you can have both."
His firm is an investor in Ant Group,and he sits on Ant's board.
Xi made no secret about what his ideal capitalist should be like. Ten days after the Ant IPO debacle,he toured a museum exhibition devoted to Zhang Jian,an industrialist who was active more than a century ago. Zhang helped build up his hometown,Nantong,and opened hundreds of schools. Business figures in the Xi era,the message went,should also put their nation ahead of business.
In a July meeting with the members of the business community,Xi pointed to Zhang as a role model and urged them to rank patriotism as their top quality. (Xi reportedly did not mention that Zhang died bankrupt.)
Ma has his own high-profile philanthropic projects,like several initiatives in rural education and a prize to help develop entrepreneurial talent in Africa. But in many other respects,the flamboyant technology entrepreneur differs greatly from Zhang.
He has long enjoyed a better reputation than his peers in manufacturing,real estate and other industries whose edge may derive from cultivating close government ties,ignoring the environmental rules or exploiting employees.
He is as famous for making bold statements and challenging authorities. In 2003,he created Alipay,which later became part of Ant Group,putting his business empire square in the centre of the state-controlled world of finance.
Now the chances that those bold statements become real have heightened.
"Given what has happened,eventually Ant will have to be controlled or even majority-owned by the state,"said Zhiwu Chen,an economist at the University of Hong Kong's business school.
It's too early to tell how far the regulators will go in reining in Ma and big tech. But some pro-market people in China worry that the country is drifting toward the hard line of the 1950s,when the party eliminated the capital class,using language that compared capitalist leanings to impurities,flaws and weaknesses.
To these people,some of the language recently used by Eric Jing,Ant's chair,evoked the era. At a conference on December 15,he said the company was"looking into the mirror,finding out our shortcomings and conducting a bodily checkup."