The long-term health of the budget is at risk from its heavy dependence on personal income tax and growing demand for spending.

The long-term health of the budget is at risk from its heavy dependence on personal income tax and growing demand for spending.Credit:James Davies

This week,Treasurer Jim Chalmers revealed the $4.2 billion surplus for the 2022-23 financial year would be“significantly” larger than expected due to stronger commodity prices,spending restraint and the strong jobs market. It would be the first budget surplus in 15 years.

According to the PBO,the long-term structure of the budget is improving in part due to those higher commodity prices as well as better wage growth,which feeds an increased tax take into Canberra’s coffers.

Gross debt is now expected to fall from 35.8 per cent of GDP in 2023-24 to 31.4 per cent in 2033-34,despite ongoing budget deficits.

But the improvement in the budget is being driven by a greater share of tax coming directly from the pockets of workers while expenses,particularly for older Australians,continue to grow.

Even with thestage three tax cuts,the average tax rate across all Australians is now on track to hit an all-time high of 27.1 per cent early next decade. This year it is expected to reach 25.5 per cent,the highest level since 2000 when tax cuts were put in place by the Howard government to offset the impact of the goods and services tax.

By early next decade,personal income tax will account for more than 50 cents of every $1 in revenue raised by the government. An additional $238 billion a year in tax is expected to be collected from workers.

Advertisement

Company tax collections are expected to climb by $59 billion. But as a share of government revenue,they will shrink from 19.3 cents in the dollar to 17.8 cents.

Loading

As the budget relies more heavily on personal income tax,the government will have to spend far more on services,primarily those aimed at older Australians and those on the National Disability Insurance Scheme.

The combined cost of aged care,the age pension and the NDIS is expected to climb from 21 per cent of all government expenditure to more than 23 per cent.

The PBO said for the tax system to be sustainable,it had to be able to absorb changes in society over time.

The growing share of older Australians needing more support and the decline in the share of working-age people were putting increasing strain on the budget’s sources of revenue.

“With an ageing population,Australia’s tax mix poses a risk to fiscal sustainability,” it said.

“For the current tax mix,with its high dependence on personal income tax,there is a trade-off between providing sufficient support for the ageing population and maintaining intergenerational fairness for younger Australians whose primary income is wages.

“Intergenerational considerations,together with projections of increasing expenditure pressures to meet the needs of the ageing population,suggest that Australia’s concentrated tax mix may pose a risk to the long-term sustainability of the tax system.”

The PBO noted that the last time Australians went more than four years without personal tax cuts was in the 1960s. The reduction in the tax burden on workers that will flow from the stage three tax cuts will be effectively wiped out by the end of the decade.

The government has been under pressure internally to re-visit the stage three tax cuts that are legislated to begin from July 1 next year. The largest gains from the cuts will flow to high-income earners,although people earning down to $46,000 will see a modest reduction in their annual tax bill.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers says a “significantly” larger budget surplus will help rebuild the nation’s financial buffers.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers says a “significantly” larger budget surplus will help rebuild the nation’s financial buffers.Credit:Alex Ellinghausen

Chalmers will use an address to the World Mining Congress in Brisbane on Thursday to argue the government is repairing the budget to protect the Australian economy from the impact of global uncertainty,higher costs and higher interest rates.

He will argue the larger-than-expected surplus would help strengthen the foundations of the nation’s finances.

“This surplus for our first year in office will be even bigger than what we forecast in May. We were deliberately restrained,cautious and conservative,methodical and responsible,” he will say.

“We wanted to rebuild our buffers,and we are. We wanted to take pressure off inflation,and we are.”

Cut through the noise of federal politics with news,views and expert analysis from Jacqueline Maley. Subscribers can sign up to our weeklyInside Politics newsletter here.

Most Viewed in Politics

Loading