Sharing a meme to condemn it is still a share.
When you ask experts about ways to limit the reach of racism and conspiracy theories on platforms such as Twitter,they'll tell you to watch how it's amplified:Sharing a meme to condemn it is still a share. Retweeting a racist tweet to shame its writer still gives the tweet more eyeballs. Even though many journalists and media organisations have gotten better at realising that trending hashtags are often more representative of the weaponisation of attention rather than a reflection of popular opinion,trending hashtags are still an effective tactic for courting news coverage of fringe ideas - even if that coverage is intended to debunk it.
Loading
Trump in particular short-circuits the usual advice. When Trump tweets a hashtag,it becomes news. And the conspiracy fringe has long known exactly how to get their tweets in front of the President.
Two weeks ago,when Trump retweeted an account supporting the QAnon conspiracy theory,The Washington Post interviewed experts on the spread of false and extreme ideas through the President's account. Becca Lewis,a research affiliate at Data&Society who studies far-right political subcultures online,argued that Trump has"turned his Twitter account into a powerful propaganda tool for some of these far-right movements."
"Whether he knows it or not,they're aware of it,"she said."The best thing they can hope for is a Trump retweet."
It"highlights the impossible position we're in,when being retweeted by the President is now the number one surefire way to enter the news cycle,"according to Whitney Phillips,an assistant professor at Syracuse University who has studied media amplification of extreme speech and misinformation online.
"Manipulators figured that out long ago. . . . You just have to find something that will stroke his ego enough or make Clinton/the Democrats look bad enough,or both,and then when he retweets it,suddenly that's the thing everyone talks about,or at least feels they have to talk about,because he's the President. It's a level of media manipulation that's almost incomprehensible,because it's such a trap:clearly dangerous and seemingly inescapable."
An analysis by Hoaxy,a tool created by Indiana University to analyse the spread of questionable hashtags - and the possible involvement of bots in promoting them - showed that even before the President's social media involvement,conservative comedian and internet personality Terrence K. Williams was a key amplifier of the #ClintonBodyCount hashtag.
"#JefferyEpstein had information on Bill Clinton&now he's dead,"read the tweet retweeted by Trump. Williams also asked his more than 500,000 followers to"RT if you're not Surprised."
For years,figures such as Williams have known that getting a hashtag trending fuels attention,and they've been good at getting it done.
Loading
Mike Cernovich,an early expert at this who rose in profile after Trump's election for his role in helping to spread the Pizzagate conspiracy theory,has long coordinated hashtag choices on live streams with his followers during breaking news. Hashtags like #ClintonBodyCount go viral before the news can catch up,in part because a bunch of people who know exactly how important it is to trend on Twitter are working to make it happen. And it's worth understanding that,while hashtags such as these are amplified by bots,the accounts spreading conspiratorial hashtags also belong to plenty of actual people. Hoaxy's analysis identified 985 Twitter accounts that were key to helping the hashtag spread;30 of those accounts had strong bot-like characteristics.
Years into his presidency,the people who are the smartest about how the internet works still don't have a great answer for how to deal with Trump's tweets - in particular,those that spread misinformation,racism or hold a megaphone for fringe voices. So the media remains in a cycle:As Trump tweets or retweets,the tweets become news,Trump tweets more about the news,and the media covers those tweets,too,inevitably sharing them with the 78 per cent of Americans not on Twitter.
And while Trump has long been clear on why he likes to tweet so much - it's a way of getting a lot of people to see what he thinks without needing to rely on the media - the punchline is that his tweets have become newsworthy by default.
Even if the media avoids spreading misinformation by engaging with these type of trending hashtags,a tweet from the President changes everything. On Sunday,the conspiracy theory was discussed on the morning politics shows. White House counsellor Kellyanne Conway,addressing Trump's retweet,toldFox News Sunday that Trump"just wants everything to be investigated."
Loading
For Phillips,the solution might come from asking a different question. Instead of considering whether Trump's tweets are newsworthy (they are),journalists should think about what kind of coverage they're doing in response to them.
"There are still stories that can be told,compelling stories,important stories,that may overlap with what's he's talking about,that aren't playing the game by his rules,"she said."He's backed us into a corner. The answer is to move to a different room."