Tasmania have hosted North Melbourne and Hawthorn but will back their own team.

Tasmania have hosted North Melbourne and Hawthorn but will back their own team.Credit:Getty

Pridham said the Swans were well-placed to make a contribution to the Tasmanian debate and the possibility of relocation as South Melbourne’s move to Sydney had eventually proved successful.

Loading

“I am very sceptical on the economics and a number of aspects - player talent for example - of a 19th team,” Pridham told3AW.

He admitted that clubs had received little information about the bid,so he was keeping an open mind ahead of the vote in August,but expressing his doubts now was appropriate as clubs needed to be economically pragmatic in considering the bid.

“We have to all keep an open mind and that includes the Tasmanian people,” Pridham said.

“At this point,all options have to be on the table. You can’t ask the clubs to have an open mind ... to Tasmania coming into the competition and a 19th licence if Tasmania can’t have an open mind to a different model.”

Advertisement

Pridham said the financial projections made ahead of Gold Coast and the Giants’ entry into the competition led to clubs backing their entry,but with the benefit of hindsight it “was fair to say[those projections] probably missed by a fair bit”. The two teams received combined AFL funding of $49 million in 2021.

The Age revealed this year that thoseexpansion clubs who play in non-traditional football states received $352 million funding from the AFL between 2012-2020.

The Tasmanian AFL Licence Taskforce presented their business case to the league at the start of 2020. Former Geelong president and AFL Commissioner Colin Carter then reviewed it last year and found the case was economically viable. He left the door open for relocation or a hybrid model but said a standalone team could work on the financial modelling done by the bid team.

The Tasmanian Government pays for Hawthorn and the Kangaroos to play home games in Launceston and Hobart.

Andrew Pridham.

Andrew Pridham.Credit:Peter Braig

The AFL committed to a vote from presidents in August,however,the retirement of Tasmanian premier Peter Gutwein,uncertainty about the real cost of a new stadium in Hobart and the AFL’s unwillingness to guarantee more than $8 million per year in funding,as the Tasmanian Government offered to commit $150 million to the team over 10 years,has stifled the bid’s momentum.

The bid team have said the financial projections weren’t dependent on a new stadium being built,but some clubs see that development as critical to a standalone team.

“If there is no stadium I don’t think there is a Tasmanian standalone team,” Pridham said.

“I have an open mind. I am emotionally very willing to see Tasmania get a great AFL experience.”

Geelong have thrown their support publicly behind Tasmania’s bid for a standalone team while Essendon president Paul Brasher is keeping an open mind.

Most Viewed in Sport

Loading