Australian National University infectious disease expert Peter Collignon said the measure would deliver some benefit,with masks providing 15 per cent protection from infection.
But the overall benefits would be small,given that when children get sick with COVID-19,they are at low risk of severe illness,he said.
“It’s a fallacy that children are a major way that COVID spreads,” Collignon said.
“That’s true for influenza – they have a four or five times higher rate of infection than adults. But that’s not true for COVID. For COVID,it’s 20 to 40-year-olds – their parents – who have always had it more often than their children.“
Chair of epidemiology at Deakin University Catherine Bennett said the cost of mask-wearing to students’ learning would be significant,and the intervention should be grounded in good quality research.
“What evidence do they have to encourage schools to go this path? It might make a small difference,but is that small difference going to be worth the impact on kids’ education?”
Bennett said she was sceptical about the quality of modelling underpinning the policy and called for it to be made public.
The nature of the current outbreak was difficult to track,she said,given the mix of different variants and risk of reinfection in an “immune-escape environment”.
“It’s a whole different disease dynamic,and it’s still being treated as the same sort of growth rate,” she said.
Melbourne University epidemiologist Tony Blakely said mask-wearing in schools was a sensible measure to help flatten the curve and prevent hospitals from being overrun.
“The peak,if we do nothing,is going to go above what our health services can manage,so we need to dampen it,” he said.
However,he agreed with Collignon and Bennett that a classic cost-benefit analysis showed the benefits were marginal compared with the costs to schools and students.
Both Thomas and Education Minister Natalie Hutchins said the altered messaging on mask-wearing on Monday night was “not a change in policy” but rather an attempt to ensure families were aware of the health minister’s recommendations as respiratory illness cases increase in Victoria.
“I think the messages have been clear and they’ve been very well taken up by the education system,” Thomas said.
Independent School Victoria recommended to its member schools last week that masks be worn in the classroom.
School staff are also expected to wear masks except in “teaching circumstances when clear communication” is needed.
School Principals Association president Andrew Dalgleish said he had “absolutely no idea” how many children would be wearing masks in classrooms by Wednesday.
“As you’ve seen this morning,we’re caught in a catch-22 situation,” he told 3AW’s breakfast radio show.
Loading
“When masks were mandated last year,people were up in arms. While it’s not a mandate,people are saying,‘well we shouldn’t be forcing the wearing of masks’. But we’re not;we’re actively encouraging people to take an action that we know will minimise the spread of this disease[COVID-19].”
The advice came as Thomas reiterated it was “strongly recommended” people wear masks indoors and in crowded places,but said there would be no mandate.
On Tuesday,Thomas told ABC’sMornings With Virginia Triolithat the state government needed to give parents the “information to make their own decision”.
“The best tool is information. We need to take our time and continue to educate and explain to those parents who are concerned about mask-wearing why it works,” she said.
“What I have seen is an additional take-up of mask-wearing over the past week or so,as people are informing themselves and learning about the current wave of the Omicron virus.”
She said the heads of Victoria’s school systems decided to send the letter to parents and were not directed to do so by the Department of Education.
Blakely said he would strongly support the same messaging for workplaces and lambasted state and federal governments as “missing in action” due to their lack of public health messaging recently and of enforcement of mask-wearing on public transport.
Loading
Victorian Opposition Leader Matthew Guy said the school mask advice had created “total confusion” and there should have been a health awareness campaign on COVID-19 before the predicted Omicron wave hit.
“One minute they say there are no mandates,and the next minute they’re advising kids to wear masks. What is it?” he said.
“If we were going to have problems over winter – and we knew there would be – then why not have a campaign around COVID safety before winter.”
The Morning Edition newsletter is our guide to the day’s most important and interesting stories,analysis and insights.Sign up here.