“There’s now a coalescence of a view that you would be able to go to the High Court and stop the decision from being implemented until the minister had considered representations from the Voice,” he said.
Loading
“The political problem will be that no conservative party or person is ever going to agree to that because conservatives have a basic view of keeping unelected judges out of politics and policy.”
Craven,a Voice supporter and director of Uphold&Recognise,an organisation seeking to build support for the referendum in conservative circles,said the Coalition would be unlikely to support the draft amendment in its current form and the referendum is at risk without bipartisanship.
University of Sydney professor Anne Twomey,also a member of the legal expert group,said that while there was long-standing precedent that courts do not interfere in the workings of the parliament,the same was not true of executive decisions and there was a possibility of litigation.
“The interpretation that people are concerned about,seems an unlikely one for the court to take[but] it can’t be completely ruled out,” Twomey said.
Loading
However,she added the likely impact of a successful challenge would be a court finding that the decision must be remade,taking into the account advice from the Voice. That would cause a delay to government action which would likely only affect a very small category of decisions requiring urgency - an outcome she said was"extraordinarily narrow and unlikely".
She said one solution to protect against legal challenge,apart from removing the words executive government from the amendment,would involve the government setting up processes to ensure that the Voice’s representations were routinely taken into account.
“Just have some kind of practical system under which decision makers would routinely check to see whether there were any relevant representations to the decision-making,have the documentation that shows they took that into consideration,and then you wouldn’t have the problem of delay,” she said.
Loading
Indigenous Australians Minister Linda Burney declined on Friday to say whether she backed the Voice having a say over executive decisions,but said she would be guided by advice from the working group expected by the end of the month.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Burney will address Voice supporters in Sydney on Saturday at a barbeque organised by Sydney’s inner west council,as part of the Yes campaign’s week of action to recruit volunteers and spread awareness about the referendum.
Meanwhile,Opposition leader Peter Dutton on Friday repeated his view that the referendum was on track to fail due to a lack of detail around how the Voice will operate.
“I think the Voice is not going to get up and I don’t think it’s going to be successful,” Dutton said.