There’s an obvious solution to Oxford Street’s woes,and it’s not bike lanes

Sydney editor

Sydney’s Oxford Street has spurred more thought bubbles than hangovers. But in the rush to repair this once proud strip,the very thing that would make a real difference is perennially overlooked.

Shortly afterWorldPride finishes in March,the government will start work on a new cycleway up Liverpool Street,past Hyde Park and along Oxford Street to Taylor Square. This is the one that was originally going to go up the middle of the road until someone realised it would obstruct the Mardi Gras parade,and has been sensibly shifted to the street’s northern edge.

Construction is due to begin on the Oxford Street cycleway after Sydney WorldPride finishes in March.

Construction is due to begin on the Oxford Street cycleway after Sydney WorldPride finishes in March.City of Sydney

This push to get Sydney cycling despite itself is admirable,and we have to take a bit of a “build it and they will come” approach sometimes. But bike lanes are not going to transform Oxford Street radically – which is what it needs.

Despitethe whining,the city’s LGBTQ hub is actually doing all right,especially at night. Arguably,it is now Sydney’s leading clubbing district,with a spate of new openings – including the reopening of legendarygay club ARQ last weekend.

But during the day,it is drab. There are vacant shops,and a lot of tired old stores flogging cheap rubbish. The thoroughfare is clogged with buses,taxis and cars. Half of it is a construction site.

At least,that’s the city end. The Paddington section has undergone a splendid revival,replete with new restaurants,boutiques and a buzzy village vibe. It’s what needs to happen (and is starting to occur) at the downtown end.

Light rail has transformed George Street.

Light rail has transformed George Street.Louise Kennerley

In the great tradition of dud Oxford Street ideas,the lobby group Business Sydney came up with a clanger earlier this month:giving control of the whole strip to the City of Sydney (the Paddo end is controlled by Woollahra Council). The logic is that disjointed governance is holding the street back.

Meh. The last thing we ought to do is hand more power to the City of Sydney,which presided over the street’s malaise and dithered for 20 years. Nor will Woollahra be the strip’s saviour:this is the same council thatdeclared late-night kebabs weren’t in the public interest,can’t even approve a skate park andworked itself into a tiz about anti-racism signs.

It shouldn’t be this hard. It takes about two minutes surveying Taylor Square to realise what ought to happen. If this were Europe,it would be a public plaza,and you could grab a drink from one of the many nearby venues and sit down at tables and chairs provided for the public.

You hear endless complaints from councillors,residents’ groups and green types about how we don’t have enough public open space. Rubbish. We just don’t use our public space well. Taylor Square has a piddling market on a Saturday morning;other than that,it’s a thoroughfare. The lovely area out the front of Darlinghurst Courthouse also goes entirely unused by the public.

Taylor Square is under-utilised as public open space.

Taylor Square is under-utilised as public open space.Wolter Peeters

A lot of money is pouring into Oxford Street.The $200 million TOGA project Oxford and Foley will redevelop three whole blocks with a 75-room boutique hotel (and rooftop pool),nearly 10,000 square metres of commercial space and another 2300sqm of retail.

Moelis Australia is planning to merge the Kinselas and Courthouse Hotel sites into a mega complex right on Taylor Square. And the City of Sydney will turn the old Darlinghurst Police Station into an LGBTQ museum.

All this is good and overdue. It may yet turn Oxford Street into something truly special. But it also needs the infrastructure,the ballast – the glue – to make the precinct easily accessible and people-friendly. It needs light rail.

The state government and City of Sydney rightly crow about how the light rail has transformed George Street from an ugly,traffic-choked hellhole to a beautified,modern boulevard where people want to walk,dine and linger. Why not do this with Oxford Street,too?

You could run it all the way down past Centennial Park to Bondi Junction and,yes,to Bondi Beach. This would help redress the two great wrongs perpetrated in this area:the removal of the tram in 1960 and the failure to extend the eastern suburbs rail line all the way to the beach.

It’s essentially the same on Parramatta Road:now that Sydney has embraced light rail again,it’s a no-brainer to finally reimagine the spine of the inner west with trams and fewer cars.

We know the state government is maxed out on infrastructure mega projects. But sticking in a bike lane here and mini-museum there,or tinkering with governance arrangements,won’t alter the big picture.

What we don’t want is another endless public consultation or nauseating master planing process where bureaucrats and planners take years to come up with ideas that are then exhibited to vested interests and so-called stakeholders.

Someone with their brain screwed on just needs to come in and dictate what’s going to happen. It doesn’t take a genius to see light rail is the answer.

The Opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge,champion and inform your own.Sign up here.

Michael Koziol is Sydney Editor of The Sydney Morning Herald,based in our Sydney newsroom. He was previously deputy editor of The Sun-Herald and a federal political reporter in Canberra.

Most Viewed in National